Bukayo Saka vs. Cole Palmer: Who’s Better?
Recent stats suggest that one player is overrated while the other is underrated. While comparisons between Palmer and Saka are understandable, it’s clear that Saka is the superior winger.
Both players have continued their strong performances from last season, with a combined total of 21 goals in all competitions so far this season. Palmer has the edge with 11 contributions (6 goals and 5 assists), compared to Saka’s 10 (3 goals and 7 assists). This demonstrates their similar impact this season, leading to the comparisons.
These discussions began last season when Palmer excelled at Chelsea, generating debates about who is better. Saka, being the preferred right winger for the England national team, often finds himself compared to Palmer, as both are vying for the same position.
Palmer’s performances during the Euros, particularly after Saka’s standout displays, intensified this debate over who deserves the right-wing spot for England.
While Palmer is undoubtedly talented and receives praise from many, including Arsenal fans, Saka’s skill set is superior for several reasons.
Firstly, it’s important to recognize that they play different roles: Palmer functions more as an inside forward or attacking midfielder, while Saka is a traditional winger capable of playing both inside and outside. Thus, the comparisons can be somewhat misguided. For those still inclined to compare them, Saka excels in one-on-one situations and is one of Europe’s best at receiving the ball wide.
His ability to shield and carry the ball adds even more value in wide positions compared to Palmer, making direct comparisons less valid. This is reflected in why Gareth Southgate and Lee Carsley have favored Saka over Palmer on the right—he simply provides more.
What do you think, Arsenal fans?
